Везде
HAS RESEARCH METHODS EFFECTIVENESS GROWN IN RUSSIAN SOCIOLOGY FOR THE LAST 100 YEARS?
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
HAS RESEARCH METHODS EFFECTIVENESS GROWN IN RUSSIAN SOCIOLOGY FOR THE LAST 100 YEARS?
Annotation
PII
S0132-16250000402-8-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Yuliana N. Tolstova 
Edition
Volume 351 Issue 7
Pages
59-69
Abstract
The views on the role of mathematical methods in the empirical research of modern Russian sociologists of the early twentieth century are considered and compared with each other. Sociologists of the past are researchers who were engaged in the collection and analysis of social data mainly within the framework of zemstvo statistics. The comparison is carried out in three directions: we consider the construction of a sample, the analysis of frequency tables of different dimensions, the study of statistical relationships between features (the choice of the compared methods of data analysis, of course, was a problem, since during the twentieth century, as is known, the number of corresponding approaches has grown immeasurably). It is shown that sociologists of the past were more conscientious about their work in the sense that they did not reject the need to use formalized approaches, but carefully implemented them, analyzing the models embedded in the methods and comparing them with their own ideas about the essence of the problem being solved. This is often forgotten by modern sociologists, believing that pressing a computer button will solve a sociological problem for them.
Keywords
methods, efficiency, zemstvo statistics, mathematical methods, moral statistics
Date of publication
01.07.2013
Number of purchasers
1
Views
495
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Blyum A., Mespule M. Byurokraticheskaya anarhiya: statistiki i vlast' pri Staline. M.: Rossijskaya politicheskaya enciklopediya, 2008.


Gur'ev A. A. Proiskhozhdenie vyborochnogo issledovaniya i pervye ego opyty v Rossii // Vestnik statistiki. 1921. N 1 - 4.


Davydov Yu. N. Maks Veber i sovremennaya teoreticheskaya sociologiya. M.: Martis, 1998.


Kablukov N. A. Statistika. Teorii i metody statistiki. Osnovnye momenty ee razvitiya. Kratkij ocherk narodonaseleniya. M., 1918.


Kaufman A. A. Korrelyacionnye formuly kak orudie statisticheskogo analiza //Statisticheskij vestnik. Kn. 3. 1914 - 1915.


Kaufman A. A. Eshche k voprosu o znachenii korrelyacionnyh formul kak orudiya statisticheskogo analiza: (Po povodu statej prof. A. V. Leontovicha, prof. R. M. Orzhenckogo i I. A. Sabaneeva). M.: T-vo pechatnya SP. Yakovleva, 1916.


Kaufman A. A. Avtobiografiya // Vestnik statistiki. 1921. N 5 - 8.


Lenin V. I. Novye hozyajstvennye dvizheniya v krest'yanskoj zhizni // PSS. T. 1. M.: OGIZ, gos. izd-vo politich. literatury, 1941. S. 3 - 58.


Mamin-Sibiryak D. N. Pis'mo A. S. Maminoj // Sobr. soch. v vos'mi tomah. T. 8. M.: Gos. izd-vo hudozhestvennoj literatury, 1955.


Makarov I. Predislovie k avtobiografii A. A. Kaufmana. URL: http://demoscope.ru/week-ly/2004/0179/nauka02.php


Mills Ch. R. Sociologicheskoe voobrazhenie. M.: ID NOTA BENE, 2001.


Peshekhonov A. V. Statisticheskoe opisanie Kaluzhskoj gubernii. Kaluga, 1898.


Postnikov V. E. Yuzhno-russkoe krest'yanskoe hozyajstvo. M., 1891.


Sorokin P. A. Russkaya sociologiya v XX veke // Sociologiya v Rossii XIX - nachala XX vv. Vyp. 1. S. 139 - 148. Perevod stat'i: Sorokin P.A. Russian sociology in the twentieth century // American Journal of Sociology. 1927. Vol. 31. P. 57 - 69.


Tolstova Yu. N. Veroyatnostnye i neveroyatnostnye modeli porozhdeniya dannyh v sociologii// Matematicheskoe modelirovanie social'nyh processov. Vyp. 12 - 13. M.: Sputnik+, 2012. S. 139 - 153.


Chuprov A. A. Nravstvennaya statistika // Brokgauz F. A. (Lejpcig), Efron I. A.


(SPb.). Enciklopedicheskij slovar'. T. XXI. S. - Peterburg: Tipolitografiya I. A. Efrona, 1897. S. 403 - 408.


Chuprov A. A. O priemah gruppirovki statisticheskih nablyudenij // Izvestiya Sankt-Peterburgskogo politekhnicheskogo instituta. 1904. T. 1. Vyp. 1 - 2.


Chuprov A. A. Vyborochnoe issledovanie v CSU SSSR // Voprosy statistiki. M.: Gosstatizdat, 1960. S. 258 - 270.


Yanson Yu. E. Opyt statisticheskogo issledovaniya o krest'yanskih nadelah i platezhah. S. - Peterburg: Tip. M. Stasyulevicha, 1877.


Science in Context. 2002. V. 15. N 3.


Zarkovitch S.S. Note on the history of sampling methods in Russia // Journal of the Royal statistical of society. Series A. 1956. Vol. 119. P. 336 - 338.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate